Tata Motors Appoints Pinaki Haldar to Revive SCV Business Amid Market Share Slump

In a significant leadership transition, Tata Motors has appointed Pinaki Haldar as Vice President and Business Head of its Small Commercial Vehicle Product Unit (SCVPU). He will report directly to Girish Wagh, Executive Director of Tata Motors Commercial Vehicles (TMCV), and will be based in Mumbai.

This move arrives at a crucial crossroads. Tata Motors’ SCV business—once the linchpin of its commercial vehicle portfolio—has been navigating persistent headwinds. Declining sales, eroding market share, and evolving customer preferences have exposed deep structural vulnerabilities. The appointment of Haldar is viewed internally as both a reset and a bold bet.

Changing of the Guard Amid Market Flux

With over two decades of experience in sales, channel development, and business strategy across sectors like consumer durables, paints, and insurance, Haldar brings a fresh, outsider perspective. His most recent role was as Vice President – India Sales and International Business at Whirlpool Corporation.

While Tata Motors has confirmed his appointment, the company declined to elaborate on strategic plans, citing a silent period ahead of its Q4 FY25 earnings. Nonetheless, the timing of this leadership shift signals deeper undercurrents: a business at inflection, a strategy in flux, and a market that’s no longer playing by the old rules.

Read More: Volvo Hits 5,000 EV Truck Sales as Tesla Semi Lags Behind

Single-Digit Growth Projected for Commercial Vehicles in FY26

From Dominance to Disruption: SCV Faces the Heat

The Small Commercial Vehicle (SCV) landscape has been reshaped dramatically over the past five years. Tata’s once-iconic Ace platform, which revolutionized last-mile logistics in India, is now grappling with relevance. Rising input costs, intensified competition, and a market tilt toward higher-payload, more flexible pickups have diluted its once unchallenged value proposition.

Newer entrants like Intra showed promise but failed to scale decisively. Tata’s attempt to crack the A2 pickup segment through the Yodha and legacy models like the 207 DI hasn’t yielded consistent traction. Meanwhile, Mahindra’s Bolero range and Ashok Leyland’s Dost continue to gain both ground and mindshare.

Market Share in Retreat: Numbers That Speak Volumes

Tata Motors remains a volume leader in the A1 mini-truck segment, but the grip is loosening:

• A1 Segment (GVW ≤ 2T): FY25 Sales: 82,440 units, down from 98,454 in FY24 — a 16% YoY decline. Market share: 52.9%, down from 55.9%.
  
• A2 Segment (GVW >2T ≤ 3.5T): FY25 Sales: 56,302 units, down from 60,794 in FY24 — a 7.4% drop. Market share: Just 18.1%, far behind Mahindra (61.1%) and Ashok Leyland (19.9%).
  
• Total SCV (A1 + A2): FY25 Sales: 138,742 units out of 466,623. Market share: 29.7%, down from 32.1% in FY24.
  

Internal Upheaval and Strategic Crossroads

Haldar’s appointment follows a spate of internal changes. The exit of long-time SCV head Vinay Pathak, consolidation of national sales roles, and redistribution of dealer management to regional truck and bus heads reflect a broader restructuring.

Tata Motors has also roped in top global consulting firms—BCG, McKinsey, Egon Zehnder—to support its turnaround blueprint. However, according to internal sources, execution has lagged, and tangible progress remains elusive.

Adding to the complexity is the looming strategic separation of the CV division, expected to be carved out and listed separately. This adds pressure to show performance quickly, and Haldar’s success—or struggle—will be closely watched in that context.

B2B2C Model: Good on Paper, Limp in Practice

The SCV business had pinned hopes on a B2B2C model, designed to align with India’s new-age logistics ecosystem. The idea was sound—deepen engagement with both institutional players like Amazon, Flipkart, and Delhivery, and end-user operators via leasing, onboarding, and platform partnerships.

However, despite being in place for over 18 months, the strategy hasn’t delivered measurable impact. Execution gaps, weak on-ground traction, and limited aggregator buy-in have hampered outcomes.

Haldar, with his background in consumer-facing industries, is expected to tighten execution frameworks, build operational discipline, and restore dealer confidence. Yet, many believe the real test lies in market-level agility, not boardroom frameworks.

A Gamble or a Genius Move?

Industry watchers are split. On one hand, bringing in a leader from outside the auto industry suggests openness to unorthodox thinking—a break from incrementalism. On the other, skeptics argue it may reflect desperation more than vision.

Still, few deny that the timing is pivotal. As Tata Motors prepares its CV business for market scrutiny, the SCV unit—once the growth driver—now stands as the weakest link. Whether Haldar can reverse its fortunes, reinvent its identity, and reclaim market momentum is a question that will define more than just his tenure.

Conclusion

Tata Motors’ SCV unit is in the throes of reinvention. The market is unforgiving, the products are aging, and competition is relentless. Against this backdrop, Pinaki Haldar steps in with a mandate that’s equal parts opportunity and trial by fire. The question is not just whether he can succeed—but whether the segment, as it exists today, can be made relevant again.

• Stay updated with 91trucks for more articles and news.
• Subscribe to our YouTube channel.
• Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn.