The Real Costs of Running an EV vs Diesel Vehicle for Your Business

As businesses across India reevaluate their operational strategies in pursuit of efficiency and sustainability, a fundamental question arises: Should you invest in an electric vehicle (EV) or stick with the traditional diesel vehicle?

At first glance, the choice may seem straightforward perhaps influenced by upfront costs or familiarity. However, the real answer lies beneath the surface. From fuel expenses and maintenance cycles to government incentives and long-term operating costs, the financial implications of each option reveal a far more layered reality.

Let’s delve into the actual cost dynamics of owning and operating an electric commercial vehicle versus a commercial diesel vehicle for your business.

1. Upfront Investment: More Than Just the Price Tag

Electric commercial vehicles typically come with a higher initial price. The reason? The battery system, which is the most expensive component in EVs. However, subsidies offered by state and central governments such as FAME II incentives can significantly reduce this burden.

On the other hand, diesel vehicles usually have a lower purchase price and are widely available, making them a preferred choice for businesses looking for quick and familiar solutions. But that initial affordability can be deceptive once other factors come into play.

2. Energy and Fuel Costs: A Clear Distinction Emerges

Fuel is one of the most significant recurring costs in any fleet. Diesel prices fluctuate regularly, and with global crude markets under pressure, this volatility often impacts business margins.

Charging an electric vehicle, by contrast, costs substantially less. Depending on the region, electricity costs can range between ₹1 and ₹2 per kilometre, whereas diesel vehicles can cost ₹5 to ₹7 per kilometre in fuel consumption alone.

Over the span of several years and thousands of kilometers, this difference translates into substantial savings.

3. Maintenance: Simpler Machines, Fewer Expenses

EVs shine when it comes to maintenance. Their design eliminates many of the components found in diesel engines no oil filters, no clutch plates, no timing belts. Fewer parts mean fewer failures, and that leads to fewer service center visits.

Diesel vehicles, in contrast, are mechanically more complex. They require regular servicing, and components wear out faster under heavy usage. Add to that the rising cost of spare parts and periodic emission checks, and the long-term cost balance begins to shift.

4. Battery Replacement vs Engine Longevity

One of the primary concerns for potential EV buyers is the battery’s lifespan. Typically lasting 5 to 7 years, battery replacement is costly, though prices are gradually decreasing as technology matures.

Diesel engines, if maintained diligently, can last more than a decade. However, this longevity comes with higher cumulative maintenance costs and the risk of engine degradation over time.

So, which is better? It depends. High-mileage operations benefit more from the lower per-kilometre cost of EVs, while lower usage patterns might still favor diesel.

5. Regulatory Compliance and Environmental Costs

The regulatory tide is turning rapidly. Major cities like Delhi are already limiting the use of older diesel vehicles and imposing strict emission norms. These changes are not just environmental they’re financial, too.

Electric commercial vehicles, producing zero tailpipe emissions, easily bypass such restrictions. There are no green taxes, no emission penalties, and a significantly reduced environmental footprint, which also contributes positively to your brand image.

6. Resale Value: An Evolving Market

The secondary market for diesel vehicles is well-established. Yet, with increasing regulations and a gradual phase-out of fossil-fuel-dependent fleets, resale value may decline over time.

The resale market for electric vehicles is still nascent. However, as adoption increases and battery life improves, the depreciation gap is expected to narrow significantly.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Business

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. If your business relies on predictable routes, urban operations, and daily mileage, an electric commercial vehicle could offer unmatched long-term value.

However, for operations involving long-distance travel, limited access to charging stations, or unpredictable schedules, a commercial diesel vehicle may still prove more practical at least for now.

In the end, it's not merely a question of technology, but of context. Analyze your business needs thoroughly. Consider both current operations and future growth. And then, choose the vehicle that moves not just your goods but your business forward.

For more articles and news, stay updated with 91trucks. Subscribe to our YouTube channel and follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Linkedin for the latest videos and updates from the automotive world!